Reply To: What makes a good horror game? HOME › Forums › Games › What makes a good horror game? › Reply To: What makes a good horror game? February 17, 2020 at 8:09 pm #23924 XXDoubleHHXXParticipant FUNK: 2,146Rank: Wise Douc Most people would say jump scares or darkness but I say plot development, if you don’t tell a good story the right way then it doesn’t work.